Why Choose Canaloplasty?
So why choose canaloplasty over other more traditional glaucoma surgeries such as trabeculectomy or tubes? Well, there are number of reasons but the main one is safety.
Canaloplasty simply is a safer surgery and there are multiple studies that look at its safety profile and this can easily be compared with those of trabeculectomy and tubes shunts. For example, it’s very very rare for anyone to lose vision from canaloplasty; its not so rare with trabeculectomy. As a matter of fact, with trabeculectomy there’s a lifetime risk of loss of vision from what’s called endophthalmitis. Such a risk does not exist with canaloplasty.
Age is another factor to consider when choosing among glaucoma surgeries. For example, when you’re younger, trabeculectomy tends not to be such a good choice. There are a number of reasons for this. One is that younger people tend to have a more aggressive healing response and healing works against you with trabeculectomy. The only way to avoid that healing response is to use something called an antimetabolite, which results in a permanent loss of ability to heal in the area of the eye where the trabeculectomy was performed. This then put somebody in a lifetime risk of infection and loss of vision. Someone who’s very young has many years to be concerned about such a thing. So, for that reason, age factors in favor of canaloplasty, which does not have those lifetime risks that trabeculectomy does.
Another thing to consider is one’s refractive error. For example, people who are very near-sighted or myopic tend not to do well with trabeculectomy. Because of the risk of vision-threatening complications; in particular, one called hypotony or a very low pressure. These complications are simply more common in somebody who is myopic or near sighted and goes ahead with trabeculectomy. Although hypotony can occasionally be seen with canaloplasty, the risk is nowhere near as high as with trabeculectomy. So in general, those with open angle glaucoma, who are near sighted, are better off with canaloplasty than trabeculectomy.
If you have an active life style, its very important that you consider your glaucoma surgery options carefully. Certain types of glaucoma surgeries, such as trabeculectomy, do not go together well with active lifestyles; especially if that lifestyle involves water sports. Because with trabeculectomy, a small blister-like structures form on the eye that is very delicate and can easily be ruptured. Any kind of activity that could potentially damage that bleb should be avoided. Diving into the water without goggles is one such activity. Therefore, if you have trabeculectomy, for the rest of your life you will need to wear protective goggles, with any type of water sport. Such a restriction simply does not exist with canaloplasty.
If you’re a contact lens wearer it’s important for you to consider your surgical options because with trabeculectomy you will no longer be allowed to wear soft contact lens after surgery. The blister-like structure called the bleb is, as mentioned, very delicate and the soft contact lens can damage that. Now, it is possible for some people after glaucoma surgery to be fitted for a hard contact lens also called a rigid gas permeable lens. The soft contact lens use is out of the question after trabeculectomy surgery. With canaloplasty, once the eye has healed, one can be refitted for a soft contact lens if one desires. Generally, there may be a refractive shift after surgery, so your old contact lenses might not work so well. But with a new pair, your vision should be back to what it was.
Race is also a factor in the choice of Glaucoma surgery. For example, certain races such as African Americans tend not to do well with trabeculectomy because the healing response can be more aggressive in certain races. Trabeculectomy tends not to succeed as often, or for as long, as it would, in, say Caucasians. Such a race criteria is not an issue with canaloplasty. Indeed, canaloplasty really gained great success because of the experience of a doctor in South Africa with viscocanalostomy which is a similar type of surgery that is not quite as successful as canaloplasty but worked very well in that population which did not respond well to trabeculectomy. So, theres a very very good track record of this type of non-penetrating surgery in all races.
Medication used is another thing to consider. With traditional glaucoma surgeries, such as trabeculectomy or tubes, these surgeries generally are not offered unless glaucoma is showing progression on what we call maximally tolerated medical therapy.This is actually a bit of a misnomer because what we mean by that is medication used that is tolerated. In other words, medications used that often causes irritation, dry eyes, burning, itching, tearing, and in some cases dark circles around the eye, or dry throat/dry mouth… So, you can see that by maximally tolerated, what we really mean is, barely tolerable. And the reason for that is that generally the risk of surgery is high enough that we would not want to consider surgery as long as somebody is at least minimally tolerating their medications.
Canaloplasty allows us to think about the option of surgery earlier because its safety profile compared to the traditional surgeries is so much better. In fact it’s good enough, that when someone starts to have difficulty with their drops perhaps even with the expense of their drops, it may be worth considering canaloplasty rather than risk someone not using his or her drops because of the expense or because of the side effects; because after all, if the drops arent being used regularly, they’re really not effective.
So these are just some of the reasons why I offered canaloplasty to my patients and why if you have glaucoma you may want to consider canaloplasty over one of the more traditional glaucoma surgeries.
I hope this one’s been helpful to you in making your decision about your glaucoma treatment.
Dr. David Richardson, MD. is a Board-certified Ophthalmologist and Eye Surgeon in Southern California. He is a recognized and respected, cataract and glaucoma surgeon; and is among an elite group of eye surgeon in the country performing the highly specialized canaloplasty procedure.
Canaloplasty FAQ Videos (with Transcript)
- How Long Does Canaloplasty Take?
- How Long Will my IOP Stay Controlled With Canaloplasty?
- How Will I Need To Limit My Activities After Canaloplasty?
- How Long Has Canaloplasty Been Around?
- Why Choose Canaloplasty?
- Why Do I Perform Canaloplasty as My Primary Glaucoma Surgery?
- What Does Minimally Invasive Mean?
- What If My Natural Drainage Canal Cannot Be Fully Catheterized?
- What Are the Risks of Canaloplasty?
- What Is The Big Deal About A Bleb Anyway?
- What If Canaloplasty Doesn't Work, Can I Still Have Traditional Glaucoma Surgery?
- Is Canaloplasty Surgery Painful?
- Is Eliminating Drops Worth The Risk Of Having Canaloplasty?
- Is Canaloplasty Really Safer Than Trabeculectomy?
- Is Trabeculectomy an Option After Canaloplasty?
- Will My Insurance Cover Canaloplasty?
- Will My Vision Change After Canaloplasty?
- Will Canaloplasty Cure My Glaucoma?
- Will I Be Able To Stop Using Glaucoma Drops After Canaloplasty?
- I Have Had Glaucoma Laser Surgery, Can I Have Canaloplasty?
- I Already Had Traditional Glaucoma Surgery, Trabeculectomy. Can I Have Canaloplasty?
- I Have Used Glaucoma Drops for a Long Time, Will That Affect the Success of Canaloplasty?
- I Have Heard That Canaloplasty Is Not As Effective As Trabeculectomy
- Can I Continue To Wear Soft Contact Lenses After Canaloplasty?